# Expanded review

The independent Cloud Room review covered six still frames from the expanded edition. It checked the visible state of the saved schedule, the pending withdrawal request, the active promotion, the rejected payroll CSV save, the chart proposal and the depreciation preview. The full observations are in review/Expanded cloud review.md. A later asset take adds a visible scroll to expose the entire unavailable November submission control and its explanation. The withdrawal lesson includes separate holds on the full balance and pending-request cards.

The desktop reviewer inspected nine installed MP4s, including the revised pickup, pending cashout, CSV errors, active promotion and fully visible depreciation control. See review/Expanded desktop review.md for the exact timestamps.

# Scope of the original review

The independent reviewers checked the original 24 films. The pickup scroll has since been corrected in both affected films. See Coverage and verification.md for the current edition.

# Independent review

The release contains 23 role lessons and one stakeholder film. Its 437 caption cues cover 37.0 minutes across all exports, including the stakeholder edit. Each English track was compared with its exact narrated waveform and stage timing. The largest measured narration offset was 4 ms. All files passed full H.264 and AAC decoding, and the library was exercised directly from disk in Chrome.

## Reviewers

| Where | Effective model and effort | Evidence |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Codex desktop | GPT‑6.2 Astra, extra-high | Independent checks of the exported films, timing, field entries, app controls and offline captions. [Desktop review](review/desktop.md) |
| Cloud Room devroom | GPT‑6 Astra, extra-high | Independent image review using frames decoded from the exported MP4s, with the corresponding cue text and audio measurements. [Closing review of the corrected frames](review/closeout.md) |

The signed-in devroom provider returned HTTP 400 with code `model_not_found` for `gpt-6.2-astra`. Its account catalog offered `gpt-6-astra`. The owner selected Cloud GPT‑6 Astra and desktop GPT‑6.2 Astra, both at `xhigh`. The devroom CLI reported `model: gpt-6-astra` and `reasoning effort: xhigh` on the runs that returned findings. The room’s nested file sandbox could not open the media, so its working reviews received the decoded pictures as direct image attachments. The per-role reviews record their sample limits. Desktop inspection and waveform checks cover playback and timing.

## Changes verified

- Returning Customer login begins with empty fields. Email entry precedes masked password entry. The address lesson reopens Saved and identifies the new street. Registration, wallet and preference transitions hold on the loaded screens.
- The Rider’s matched home zone reads Lagos Island. The full Save Draft control is visible below Submit For Review, and the app shows Draft saved. The five separate document selections end on the Submitted screen.
- Vendor signup ends on a reopened application marked Draft. The settlement lesson distinguishes account-name matching, saving the account and sending a verification request. The catalogue film shows the availability control and explains the reconnecting order-feed banner.
- The pickup lesson locates Verify Pickup PIN under Kitchen Actions. Its short scroll uses overlapping pixels from two captures of the same valid-PIN state. The stakeholder edit uses the same verified sequence.
- The library can display native English captions offline. It creates the caption track from the embedded cue text, and also includes linked SRT, WebVTT, and a step transcript.

## Scope

Each reviewer’s role and chapter notes describe what was visible in their samples, any early issues and any playback checks still required at the time of that review. The closing review and final media checks cover the corrected files. A second teal pointer dot appears briefly during the Vendor pickup scroll. The button, code entry and verification result remain visible. The Rider app briefly labels its busy state “Submitting…” when saving a draft, then reports “Draft saved.” Checkout restaurant and dish cards use the training catalogue’s default thumbnails. The numbers, bank records, addresses and document images are fictional. See [the route inventory](Training%20coverage.csv) for workflows outside this edition.
